Friday, February 17, 2017

Mohawk Valley by Ronald Welch

Thanks to the good folks at Slightly Foxed, my adventures through history with Ronald Welch's Carey Family continues...

In Mohawk Valley, young Alan Carey is forced to leave Cambridge in disgrace after being accused of cheating at cards. Expelled from the college and a pariah among his erstwhile friends, Alan heads back to the ancestral home at Llanstephan to face his father, the formidable old Charles Carey familiar to readers from Captain of Dragoons. The Earl, together with his friend Mr William Pitt, comes up with a plan: ship Alan across the Atlantic to make his fortune and repair his reputation taking care of the Earl's properties on the American frontier. Once in America, Alan finds his hands full learning woodcraft and dealing with untrustworthy stewards. But not all is peaceful in the backwoods, and political maneuverings in London and Paris threaten to bring war on the frontier.

You guessed it: this is the book about the French and Indian War. Overall, I have to say that this is my least favourite of the Carey Family series so far. The plot was more episodic than most of Welch's other books, and I didn't at all care for the portrayal of one of the villains as a Scripture-quoting fanatic who first cheats and then attempts to murder our hero. The New England Puritans had their oddities, especially as time went on, but as a general rule they were sincere, law-abiding people, and I felt that by making their sole representative in this book a villain, Welch was trying to say something about the Puritans, and sincere religious faith, as a whole.

Still, there was plenty to like about Mohawk Valley. Ronald Welch wrote for young people, especially young boys, but I usually find his books full of thoughtfulness on topics of maturity and manhood. One thing that I think all his books have in common is that they challenge their young heroes, and through them the readers, with difficult decisions and tasks. And one of the reasons why this is so challenging to the reader is that Welch does a very good job of showing how difficult his heroes find their tasks: he writes sympathetically to their fears and doubts in such a way that he seems sympathetic to the fears and doubts of the reader too.

So, in Mohawk Valley, Alan Carey faces nearly the most depressing fate for any young member of the English nobility: when he elects to fight a duel to clear his name, his nerves fail him and he drops his pistol, convincing everyone present that he's not just a cheat but also a coward. Alan heads home convinced that he's shamed not just himself but also his family name and his swashbuckling old father. The rest of the book is about how he rediscovers his courage and self-respect, even as he relinquishes his status as an English nobleman for the harsher and more egalitarian life of an American backwoodsman. There's more than one way of being brave, and more than one way of being noble, the book seems to say: if you fail at one thing, pick yourself up and try another. I can imagine that being a fairly encouraging thing for a young man to read.

The last third or so of the book is taken up with the French and Indian War, with fairly detailed accounts of the battle of Ticonderoga and the fall of Quebec. As usual, Welch writes about wars without criticising the diplomatic decisions that cause them, but his battle scenes are always vivid, visceral and intensely serious.

Mohawk Valley may not be my favourite Welch book, but it contains all the things that make the rest of the series worth reading: historical detail, military realism, and sympathetic characters facing tough decisions. The series is currently in print in beautiful limited editions available from Slightly Foxed - particularly recommended for home educators!


Jamie W said...

This is quite tangential to your excellent review, but I was looking at the series summaries on the Slightly Foxed link and I have to wonder--do they *all* go to Cambridge? :-)

Suzannah said...

Haha, they probably all do; which is odd, for a serious originally published by Oxford University Press!

Unknown said...

I loved this one when I was a kid!

Suzannah said...

Joffre, I'm amazed! Ronald Welch is nowhere near as well-known as he should be, so it's always fun to find someone else that enjoyed reading him. Did you ever read any of his other books? KNIGHT CRUSADER, CAPTAIN OF DRAGOONS and TANK COMMANDER are all, IMO, even better than this one.

Unknown said...

No, I never did, this is the only one. I've had a fascination with the French & Indian and 18th century frontier life ever since discovering Kenneth Roberts as a teen.

Nick said...

Nice to see Welch's Carey books back in print. I read most of them as a child and the
rest later on when I could find them. The first book I read where the hero died was
"Captain of Foot" and Welch wasn't afraid to kill characters off - 2 books end with
a dead Carey and various cousins and brothers also meet their end.

Some Careys are rather unpleasant at first but mature into better people over the course of the books.

Suzannah said...

Hi Nick, yes, it is nice to see the Carey books back in print!

I'm glad you enjoyed the review, but might I ask that you put spoiler warnings on your comments? I haven't read CAPTAIN OF FOOT yet myself and other readers who haven't read it might also like not to know what happens :)


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...